The Pizza Shop

Discover delicious NY-style pizza at The Pizza Shop in San Francisco. Enjoy pizza by the slice, fresh toppings like pesto, cherry peppers, white mushrooms, and more—cash only. Located at 3104 24th St, call us at +1 415-824-1840!

Welcome to The Pizza Shop

Experience the finest dining

The Pizza Shop
The Pizza Shop
The Pizza Shop
The Pizza Shop

Step into The Pizza Shop, a slice of pizza paradise nestled in the heart of San Francisco. This cozy eatery, located at 3104 24th St, boasts a vibrant, welcoming atmosphere that draws in locals and visitors alike. Known for its NY-style pizza, the restaurant serves up pies and slices that pack a punch of flavor. Patrons rave about the delicious cherry pepper and pesto pizza, perfect for those craving something unique. Whether indulging in a full pie or grabbing a quick slice, expectations soar with every bite.

With its bustling environment, The Pizza Shop thrives on Saturday evenings, a true testament to its popularity.

The aroma of freshly baked crust fills the air while the cheerful chatter of happy customers creates an upbeat vibe. Grab a seat, settle in, and prepare for a pizza experience that keeps the community coming back for more.

The Pizza Shop excels in delivering top-notch pizza, featuring a menu rich with 15 distinct offerings, each prepared with care. The standout items include "The Meat," bursting with savory flavors, and unique selections like cherry pepper and pesto, which bring a delightful twist to traditional pizza.

This restaurant operates a cash-only policy, adding a retro touch to your dining experience. It welcomes patrons with both dine-in and take-out options, making it easy to enjoy a slice anywhere. Notice how some prefer to savor their meal inside, soaking in the lively ambiance, while others grab a slice to go, taking a piece of the shop's magic with them.

Peak times can see the place packed, especially on Saturdays at 5 PM when it reaches 100% capacity. Yet, quieter times during weekdays allow for a more relaxed dining experience, providing flexibility for all schedules.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

3104 24th St, San Francisco, CA 94110, United States

Phone

+1 415-824-1840

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

The Pizza Shop
The Pizza Shop
The Pizza Shop
The Pizza Shop

Established with the goal of serving authentic New York-style pizza, The Pizza Shop has become a beloved local gem. Its commitment to quality ingredients shines in every slice, and the diverse menu caters to varied tastes. Each pizza is crafted with fresh dough, a rich tomato base, and a variety of toppings to satisfy even the pickiest eaters. Here, pizza isn't just food; it's a community experience, bringing people together in a lovely setting.

The menu features crowd favorites like "White Spinach" and "Pepperoni & Pineapple," ensuring everyone finds something they love. Priced around $31.40 for an average pizza, this shop strikes a balance between quality and affordability. The consistency in taste keeps customers returning for more, while the innovative flavors make it a place worth exploring. As patrons take their first bite, they're often transported back to memories of a bustling New York pizzeria, where every meal feels like a celebration.

Operating on a cash-only basis may feel old-school, but it adds to the authenticity and charm. The friendly staff fosters a warm, inviting atmosphere, welcoming newcomers and regulars alike. Whether sharing a table with friends or enjoying a solo lunch on his or her way to work, each visit becomes an integral part of the neighborhood fabric.

Families, friends, and pizza lovers unite here to create memories around a shared love for pizza. The sociable vibe attracts a diverse crowd, and the shop actively engages with the community, supporting local events and gatherings.

The Pizza Shop

The Pizza Shop presents a charming exterior, drawing in foot traffic with its vibrant signage and cozy patio area. Located conveniently on 24th St, the shop’s storefront features window displays showcasing mouth-watering slices, tantalizing enough to make anyone stop and take a look.

As customers approach, the invigorating scent of baked crust wafts through the air, inviting them in for a treat. The outdoor seating area beckons those wanting to enjoy their pizza al fresco. The friendly vibe extends from inside to the streets, echoing the heart of the vibrant San Francisco culture.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday12-9 PM
  • Monday12-9 PM
  • Tuesday12-9 PM
  • Wednesday12-9 PM
  • Thursday12-9 PM
  • Friday12-10 PM
  • Saturday12-10 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Thank god we came here for our first pizza in the San Fran area!!! It was so good well worth every dollar, if your complaining about the price you need to realize this is the San Fran market price 5-7 bucks a slice of pizza. We are from New Jersey, and we know pizza east coast, and let me tell you this pizza was bomb, better then the pizza back home and NYC. turns out the owner is from NJ, I can see why its a hidden gem of a great pizza. reason why I said thank god we came here first, because the next day we were craving pizza again, and we were far away, and made the assumption all San Fran pizza must be good, so we decided to go to the very famous so called Tony pizza...... wow we were so mad, and felt so stupid seeing all the hype that pizza sucked!!!! no taste, no sauce, just a bland piece of bread. I have no idea how that place became famous, but if this owner opened next to them it would be over, like real quick. I will always tell my friends now if you want good food in San Fran look no place other then Mission district!!! All the food is Fire in this area, Thai, pizza everything!!!

N
Neil S.

They say "Believe in pizza again". Well, I restored my trust in pizza. I'm so glad I stopped by at this pizza spot. It was just by chance. As a person who loves nyc-style pizza, I savored every bite. We had pesto jalapeno, white spinach, and pepperoni mushroom. The dough was flat and crispy, not starchy. I could taste the freshness of tomatoes from the sauce. Pepperoni wasn't overly salty and true to how it should taste like. Pesto jalapeno had a tasty kick which I loved so much. Every piece was purely pleasant. Can't wait to throw a pizza party with friends with their whole pizzas.

F
Fiona L.

Really, really good pizza; probably one of my new favorites in SF. The dough is almost New York-y, just a bit too thin, and it's got a wonderful SF sourdough-y twist which enhances the pizza so much. The shop is a very simple few tables in the same room as the pizza oven. But when the slices are this good, who cares what the shop looks like

M
Matt B.

Been searching for a casual place to get NY style pizza by the slice with crispy crust, and was recommended this place. It was quick to get our slice, and was indeed crispy. We got the pepper and pesto slice, it was spicier than we had expected. Will need to try their other slices next time.

A
Annie

Awesome pizza. Very light for pizza. Perfectly crispy, no flop. Tangy sauce. Nice owner/employees. Spacious environment with open windows and very clean. Clean bathroom too.

M
Marshall H.

Absolutely speechless. One of the only places in San Francisco that I've found that can make a perfectly competent NY Slice. Nice wide slices. Crispy cracker thin crust. No flop. Had the white pie and combo and both were solid pizzas. Comfortable seating and plenty of space. Feels modern compared to some of the more run down places in the city. Will be back anytime I'm craving a NY slice. They take cash and card.

J
James K.